Journalist Banned from Alberta Hospitals
The CCF is seeking judicial review after Alberta Health Services (AHS) banned independent journalist Mocha Bezirgan from all AHS properties across Alberta for one year.
On March 8, 2021, the CCF launched a legal challenge of the federal quarantine hotel requirement. Joining the CCF as applicants are five other individuals who wish to fight this unjustified limit on their Charter-protected rights to enter Canada. Forcing Canadians to pay up to $2,000 out of pocket for hotel expenses cannot be justified when more proportional response to the COVID-19 pandemic are possible. They are unnecessary when piled on top of existing requirements, like the requirements for multiple tests and to quarantine in your own home for 14 days. Some health measures are necessary to combat COVID-19, but these quarantine hotels get the balance wrong. We can prevent the spread of COVID-19 while still protecting the fundamental rights of Canadians.
The individual applicants in the challenge brought by the CCF are all travelling for compassionate reasons. For example, three applicants wish to travel to attend to the end of the life of parent in another country. One applicant left Canada to attend a funeral, and another needs to travel to assist a spouse resident in another country while she undergoes surgery. While there are exemptions from the quarantine hotels for travelers entering Canada for compassionate reasons, there are no specific exemptions for travellers who must leave Canada for compassionate reasons.
The CCF is challenging the quarantine hotel policy on the grounds that it is a violation of the Charter protected right to enter Canada (s. 6), the Charter protected right to liberty (s. 7), the Charter protected right to be free from arbitrary detention (s. 9), and the Charter protected right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment (s. 12). The CCF is seeking an urgent injunction, a declaration that the quarantine requirement is unconstitutional, and monetary damages in the amount of the estimated hotel costs.
The CCF is represented by Toronto lawyer Jonathan Roth.
On July 5, 2021 a decision was announced. See our full release.
Related Cases
Real Estate Regulator Targets Political Speech
The CCF secured a free speech victory for B.C. realtor Corbin Chivers after his professional regulator withdrew a caution letter over political views he expressed online.
Toronto’s Right to Bike Lanes (Cycle Toronto v Ontario)
The Canadian Constitution Foundation is intervening in the Ontario government’s appeal of a court ruling that prevented the removal of several downtown Toronto bike lanes, arguing the decision improperly expands Section 7 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms into a positive right to bike lanes.