Regulator Searches of Workplace Devices
The CCF is intervening in a Supreme Court of Canada case to defend Canadians’ privacy rights when personal information is stored on employees’ workplace devices and systems.
The Canadian Constitution Foundation intervened in a novel case at the Ontario Supreme Court in 2023 about the constitutionality of Canada’s first-past-the-post voting system.
First-past-the-post voting (FPTP) is Canada’s electoral system, inherited from the United Kingdom. Under this system, winning candidates do not need to win a majority, they just need to receive more votes than anyone else. Two organizations – Springtide and Fair Voting BC – are arguing in their constitutional challenge that the FPTP system violates the Charter guaranteed right to vote and the right to equality because citizens do not have equal voting power (votes for a losing candidate are “wasted”). These advocacy groups also argue that FPTP discriminates against women and minorities by contributing to their under representation.
The Canadian Constitution Foundation intervened with the position that the system does not violate the constitution, and indeed, that provisions of the Constitution Act, 1867, established Canada’s FPTP system by creating a system of constituency-based representation for the House of Commons where each electoral district is represented by a single Member of Parliament.
The simple fact is that whether FPTP is politically unfair is not an issue for courts: it is a policy question!
Victory: The Canadian Constitution Foundation was pleased that the Ontario Supreme Court agreed with the CCF’s arguments in a decision that finds the first-past-the-post system of voting is constitutional.
The CCF was then pleased to see Ontario Court of Appeal dismiss the case.
Related Cases
Firearms “Variants” Prohibition
The CCF is intervening at the Supreme Court of Canada in a challenge to federal firearms regulations that prohibit a broad range of firearms and their “variants.” The case arose after the Trudeau government in 2020 issued a regulation prohibiting a long list of what they called “military-style assault weapons” and their “variants.” The RCMP…
Rebuilding Ontario Place Act (Ontario Place Protectors v Ontario)
The CCF is intervening at the Supreme Court of Canada in a constitutional challenge to Ontario’s Rebuilding Ontario Place Act (ROPA), legislation tied to the provincial government’s redevelopment of Ontario Place, a defunct waterfront amusement park. ROPA, passed in 2023, exempts the redevelopment from most requirements under the Environmental Assessment Act and the Ontario Heritage…